In its fourth season, the American iteration of Traitors has brought together a compelling new group of pseudo-celebrities—from Real Housewives like Dorinda Medley and Porsha Williams to so-called gamers like Survivor's Natalie Anderson and Big Brother's Tiffany Mitchell to figure skating legends Johnny Weir and Tara Lipinski—to compete for a grand prize of up to $250,000. Upon arriving at Cumming's castle in the first episode, the group was eager to head to the initial blindfolded round table and find out whether they had been selected to play as a Traitor or Faithful. But this time around, the contestants were immediately thrown for a loop when their host revealed there would be an additional "Secret Traitor," one whose identity was kept hidden from everyone (including those of us watching at home).